The computing infrastructure as a service offered by Amazon Web Services (AWS) may have originally been conceived as a resource to support their own electronic commerce business but other striking applications emerged. Netflix toppled Blockbuster and transformed the way we consume video atop the AWS infrastructure. Dropbox changed the way we store and share digital resources by building on AWS. My company Crowdmark leverages AWS to store and serve images of student work for evaluation by graders and further analysis. Recently, the Google Cloud Vision API, the IBM Watson Developer Cloud and the Receptiviti.ai API started offering artificial intelligence as a service available for purchase like a utility. These resources may form the foundation for a new era of technological metamorphosis.

Experimenting with Text Analysis

I wondered whether text analysis might generate useful insights for Crowdmark or other applications so I performed some experiments. I ran the texts from inaugural addresses by four presidents of the United States through some text analysis tools I found online. The IBM Watson Tone Analyzer uses “cognitive linguistic analysis methods” to measure the emotional tone in text. The Linguistic Inventory Word Count (LIWC) is a computer text analysis tool developed and psychometrically validated by James Pennebaker. Receptiviti.ai is a Toronto-based startup that offers text analysis as a service based on LIWC and other technology.

The texts

The tools

Screen captures of the results appear below.

Conclusion

The IBM Watson Tone Analyzer results are exposed within an intuitive and interactive user interface. The results do not correspond well with my own emotional response reviewing the videos or reading these speeches. Based on these experiments, I am not convinced that Tone Analyzer will generate useful insights into the emotional characteristics of text. Based on what I observed, there appear to be too few dimensions of emotional tone generated by Tone Analyzer for it to drive improvements to the dialogue between instructors and students. There may be a rich superset of output measurements not exposed in this free demonstration.

The LIWC results exposed through this free sample analysis are a small collection of the many dimensions measured by LIWC. It is not easy to glean insights into the speaker’s personality or their emotional tone based on the reports externalized in this free demo.

Short text descriptions of personality traits of the speaker emerged in the results from Receptiviti.ai. I found the text descriptions interesting but with limited precision in describing the speakers. I’m curious to know whether the personality decription accuracy increases with larger text samples from the same speaker.

Files of various types (text, images) may now be sent to increasingly sophisticated online analysis engines poised and ready to extract data and return insights to the sender. What will your robot assistant read for you tomorrow?


Experiments with IBM Watson Tone Analyzer

IBM Watson Tone Analyzer

Reagan Experiment

As a first experiment, I copied the text from the January 20, 1981 Inaugural Address of President Ronald Reagan (video) and pasted it into the IBM Watson Tone Analyzer. Here are the overview results:

reagan

Moving the mouse over portions of the text reveals the results of tonal analysis of the highlighted paragraph.

reagan paragraph

Tonal dimensions can be highlighted and sentences can be ranked based on tonal strength. For example, here is the sentence ranked highest for Disgust.

selected tone and sentence rank

Clinton Experiment

As a second experiment, I processed the text from the January 20, 1993 Inaugural Address of President Bill Clinton (video) with Tone Analyzer. Here are the overview results:

clinton

Tone Analyzer reports that Clinton’s speech is most dominated by Fear.

fear

Kennedy Experiment

For a third experiment, I chose the text from January 20, 1961 Inaugural Address of President John Kennedy (video):

kennedy

anger-kennedy

Eisenhower Experiment

For the final experiment, I processed the text from January 21, 1957 Inaugural Address of President Dwight Eisenhower (video):

eisenhower ike-fear

Overview Comparisons using IBM Watson Tone Analyzer

Reagan 1980 reagan Clinton 1993 clinton 1993 Kennedy 1961 kennedy 1961 Eisenhower 1957 eisenhower 1957


Experiments with LIWC

LIWC

  • Reagan via LIWC reagan-liwc
  • Clinton via LIWC clinton-liwc
  • Kennedy via LIWC kennedy-liwc
  • Eisenhower via LIWC eisenhower-liwc

Experiments with Receptiviti Personality Insights

Receptiviti.ai

  • Reagan via Receptiviti.ai reagan-receptiviti
  • Clinton via Receptiviti.ai clinton-receptiviti
  • Kennedy via Receptiviti.ai kennedy-receptiviti
  • Eisenhower via Receptiviti.ai eisenhower-receptiviti